Compare YMAG vs MAG4

YMAG is a YieldMax Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) designed for diversification, and consists of the following funds:
NVDY, TSLY, AMZY, FBY, GOOY, APLY, & MSFO.

In this comparison, we introduce MAG4, a focused strategy that equally invests ONLY in four top-performing ETFs:
NVDY, TSLY, AMZY, and FBY. Starting from 2024-01-30, MAG4 achieved a 50.71% higher total return vs YMAG!

Compare YMAG vs MAG4:

This tool allows you to compare total returns for a $10,000 invested into YMAG and MAG4, split equally into underlying funds, with & without dividend reinvestment (DRIP) as well as adjust starting date.

Start Date: Compare

The results above clearly show that MAG4 outperformed YMAG in both total returns and dividends.

See detailed report for each of MAG4 stocks: NVDY, TSLY, AMZY and FBY

Summary of YMAG vs MAG4 Returns:

With dividend reinvestment (DRIP), MAG4 earned $8,721, compared to YMAG’s $5,007.

Even without DRIP, MAG4’s dividends totaled $6,226, surpassing YMAG’s $4,091.

MAG4’s advantage comes from its focused strategy of selecting high-performing ETFs like NVDY and TSLY, while YMAG’s broader diversification, including underperformers like GOOY, APLY, and MSFO, held it back.

Here are some key takeaways from the comparison:

• Higher Returns: MAG4 achieved a total return with DRIP of 29.32%, compared to YMAG’s 19.46%. Without DRIP, MAG4 still led with a return of 28.99%, versus YMAG’s 19.74%.
• Better Dividend Performance: MAG4 consistently delivered higher dividends both with and without DRIP.
• Strategic Focus: MAG4 focuses on high-yield ETFs like NVDY and TSLY, avoiding lower-performing options like GOOY, APLY, and MSFO.

Dividend Payouts & DRIP Share Accumulation

Table below shows the progress for each fund - dividend payment date, total amount paid, and total shares for the period after devidends were reinvested (DRIP).

"-" indicates no dividend payment for the Stock/ETF for that period.

Payouts Per Share

This table shows dividend amount per share for each Stock/ETF and total amount per share collected from start date.

For investors looking to maximize growth and income, the "MAG4" might be a good option, as it demonstrates the value of a carefully curated ETF strategy. This comparison highlights how a more targeted approach can deliver better results than broader diversification.